Quick summary: 5 key points
  • Sommer v. Kridel (1977) requires a landlord to make a reasonable effort to re-let after a residential tenant wrongfully leaves.
  • The landlord must prove it used reasonable diligence in trying to re-let the unit.
  • A landlord with other empty apartments must treat yours as one of its vacant stock.
  • Kridel's own lease said failure to re-let would not end his rent liability. The court still reversed the landlord's judgment.
  • No New Jersey statute section we read states the duty. No Newark chapter we read sets a re-renting rule.

Did this answer your question?

Was this guide helpful?Your answer is anonymous and helps us fix what is unclear.

Step by step

How it plays out

  1. You leave earlyLandlord must try to re-letUnder Sommer v. Kridel, a landlord must make a reasonable effort to mitigate damages when a residential tenant wrongfully leaves.
  2. Unit sits emptyTreated like other vacant unitsA landlord with other vacant apartments must treat yours as one of them. Showing or advertising the unit is one factor.
  3. Bill arrivesLandlord proves its diligenceThe landlord carries the burden of proving reasonable diligence. You may show suitable tenants you put forward who were rejected.

Copy and send: When your landlord bills you for rent after you moved out early

Ask what was done to re-let the unit

Fill in the brackets and keep a copy of what you send.

How New Jersey compares

Landlord duty to mitigate after an early lease break, state by state

Landlord duty to mitigate after an early lease break by stateEach square is a state; New Jersey is outlined.AlabamaALNo figureAlaska: guide coming soonAKArizonaAZNo figureArkansas: guide coming soonARCaliforniaCANo figureColoradoCONo figureConnecticut: guide coming soonCTDelaware: guide coming soonDEDistrict of ColumbiaDCNo figureFloridaFLNo figureGeorgiaGANo figureHawaii: guide coming soonHIIdahoIDNo figureIllinoisILNo figureIndianaINNo figureIowaIANo figureKansas: guide coming soonKSKentuckyKYNo figureLouisiana: guide coming soonLAMaine: guide coming soonMEMarylandMDNo figureMassachusettsMANo figureMichiganMINo figureMinnesotaMNNo figureMississippi: guide coming soonMSMissouriMONo figureMontana: guide coming soonMTNebraskaNENo figureNevadaNVNo figureNew Hampshire: guide coming soonNHNew JerseyNJNo figureNew MexicoNMNo figureNew YorkNYNo figureNorth CarolinaNCNo figureNorth Dakota: guide coming soonNDOhioOHNo figureOklahomaOKNo figureOregonORNo figurePennsylvaniaPANo figureRhode Island: guide coming soonRISouth Carolina: guide coming soonSCSouth Dakota: guide coming soonSDTennesseeTNNo figureTexasTXNo figureUtahUTNo figureVermont: guide coming soonVTVirginiaVANo figureWashingtonWANo figureWest Virginia: guide coming soonWVWisconsinWINo figureWyoming: guide coming soonWY

No figureGuide coming soonYou are here

See all 33 cities as a chart

Landlord duty to mitigate after an early lease break

Same clause, 33 cities, different rules. Tap any city for its own guide.

Austin, Texas
Mandatory, non-waivable
Los Angeles, California
Mandatory, tenant proves
New York City, New York
Mandatory, non-waivable
Miami, Florida
No duty to re-rent
Chicago, Illinois
Mandatory statewide
Seattle, Washington
Mandatory on abandonment
Denver, Colorado
No statute; case law
Phoenix, Arizona
Mandatory after abandonment
Atlanta, Georgia
Likely no duty
Nashville, Tennessee
Mandatory in large counties
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
No duty to re-rent
Portland, Oregon
Mandatory on abandonment
Boston, Massachusetts
No statute; 93A limits
Las Vegas, Nevada
Mandatory on abandonment
Washington, District of Columbia
Mandatory, actual damages
Columbus, Ohio
No statute; case law
Newark, New Jersey
Mandatory, landlord proves
Detroit, Michigan
Non-waivable by lease
Charlotte, North Carolina
Case law; tenant proves
Baltimore, Maryland
Mandatory, non-waivable
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Mandatory on abandonment
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Mandatory; acceleration voids lease
Kansas City, Missouri
No general duty; deposit rule
Indianapolis, Indiana
Case law duty to re-let
Louisville, Kentucky
Mandatory on abandonment
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Mandatory statewide
Salt Lake City, Utah
Case law; landlord proves
Richmond, Virginia
Mandatory; no accelerated rent
Albuquerque, New Mexico
Statutory duty; may on abandonment
Birmingham, Alabama
Mandatory on abandonment
Des Moines, Iowa
Mandatory on abandonment
Omaha, Nebraska
Mandatory statewide
Boise, Idaho
Case law; on abandonment

Figures are the state rule, or the stronger city ordinance where one exists. Verify the current law for your own situation before relying on it.

Understanding the Lease Acceleration Clause

An acceleration clause is the lease paragraph that makes all the rent left on your term due at once if you fall behind or move out early. On paper, every month still to run becomes payable now.

In New Jersey, what a landlord can collect for the empty months also depends on what it did to re-let the unit, and on proof the landlord has to produce. This page explains the court decision that sets that rule for Newark renters.

What renters assume

My lease says the landlord's failure to re-rent will not reduce what I owe, so I must pay every month left.

What is actually true

Not necessarily. Kridel's lease "stipulated that failure to re-let or to recover the full rental would not discharge the tenant's liability for rent". The court still held the landlord had to make a reasonable effort to mitigate, and reversed the judgment in the landlord's favor.

Not one of the 33 rows in the comparison above carries a figure; each is a short label. Newark's reads Mandatory, landlord proves.

Twenty of the 33 labels open with Mandatory: Austin, Los Angeles, New York City, Chicago, Seattle, Phoenix, Nashville, Portland, Las Vegas, Washington, Newark, Baltimore, Minneapolis, Milwaukee, Louisville, Oklahoma City, Richmond, Birmingham, Des Moines and Omaha. Of the other thirteen, Miami and Philadelphia read No duty to re-rent, Atlanta reads Likely no duty, Kansas City reads No general duty; deposit rule, Denver and Columbus read No statute; case law, Boston reads No statute; 93A limits, Detroit reads Non-waivable by lease, Charlotte reads Case law; tenant proves, Indianapolis reads Case law duty to re-let, Salt Lake City reads Case law; landlord proves, Albuquerque reads Statutory duty; may on abandonment, and Boise reads Case law; on abandonment.

Four labels name who has to prove the point, and they point at opposite parties. Los Angeles reads Mandatory, tenant proves and Charlotte reads Case law; tenant proves; Salt Lake City reads Case law; landlord proves, and Newark's rests on Sommer v. Kridel, where the landlord proves it used reasonable diligence to re-let.

Like Denver and Columbus, Newark's answer comes from a court, yet its label opens with Mandatory.

Clause decoder

Rent Acceleration Clause Example - What the Wording Looks Like in Newark, NJ

The sample clause below comes from a Montana court case, and the notes explain what New Jersey law says about each part. It is real lease language - a court quoted it word for word, and then ruled on it. What the judge decided is at the bottom of this block.

Real clause - quoted in a published court opinion

Find the equivalent paragraph in your own lease and read the two side by side. The wording will differ; the moving parts rarely do.

This is the lease paragraph as the court quoted it, stopped one sentence early. The sentence left out deals with late charges and interest running on an amount once it has been accelerated:

If any monthly installment under this agreement is not paid when due and remains unpaid after a date specified by a notice to Tenant, the entire principal rent amount owed for the full lease term shall at once become due and payable at the option of the Landlord and judgment may be had for all said amounts due. The foregoing provision shall not relieve the Landlord of its obligation to mitigate damages. In the event the rental premises is re-rented to another for full value prior to expiration of the lease term, Landlord shall file Notice of Partial Satisfaction of any judgment entered to the extent of the third party rental agreement.

[…]

Quoted from the published opinion in Summers v. Crestview Apartments, 2010 MT 164, 357 Mont. 123, 236 P.3d 586 (No. DA 09-0489). Judicial opinions are not subject to copyright; the lease language is reproduced in limited part for commentary under 17 U.S.C. § 107.

What the 4 highlighted phrases mean
1

“principal rent amount owed for the full”

This is the balance the paragraph converts into one debt. In Sommer v. Kridel, New Jersey's Supreme Court held “that a landlord does have an obligation to make a reasonable effort to mitigate damages” when a residential tenant wrongfully leaves. It overruled Joyce v. Bauman “to the extent that it is inconsistent with our decision today”. The total a lease names is where a claim starts, and Sommer attaches a duty to it.

See the example
Assume rent of $1,650 a month and nine months left: this sentence asks for $14,850 on a single day. If you have moved out, Sommer turns the next question to what the landlord did over those months to re-let the unit, and puts the proof on the landlord. Sommer states that rule for a tenant who leaves, not for one still living in the unit.
Tenant-favourable“Only installments already past due may be demanded, and each later month is owed only while the unit stays empty despite Landlord's reasonable efforts to re-let it.”
What this lease said“principal rent amount owed for the full”
Landlord-favourable“The whole balance of the Term is a fixed debt on default, owed in full whatever becomes of the unit afterwards.”
2

“of the Landlord and judgment may”

Judgment is the point where New Jersey puts the weight on the landlord's side. Sommer says “the landlord shall be required to carry the burden of proving that he used reasonable diligence in attempting to re-let the premises”. California runs the other way: under Cal. Civ. Code § 1951.2 the tenant carries the burden of proving what rental loss could reasonably have been avoided.

See the example
Ask in writing what was done to re-let, and when, before you discuss any figure.
Tenant-favourable“No judgment shall be sought for any month unless Landlord shows the reasonable efforts made to re-let the unit during that month.”
What this lease said“of the Landlord and judgment may”
Landlord-favourable“Judgment may be entered for the full balance on Landlord's statement of default alone, without proof of any attempt to re-let.”
3

“relieve the Landlord of its obligation to”

This lease concedes the duty. The lease in Sommer said close to the reverse. Kridel's lease “stipulated that failure to re-let or to recover the full rental would not discharge the tenant's liability for rent”, and the opinion ends “The judgment in Sommer v. Kridel is reversed”. The court saw “no distinction between the leases involved in the instant appeals and those which might arise in other types of residential housing”.

See the example
Sommer reports that lease and that result; it has no separate sentence on lease waivers. Texas voids a waiver of the duty in Tex. Prop. Code § 91.006; our New Jersey record holds no counterpart section. Read the current text of Sommer yourself before treating any lease sentence as settled.
Tenant-favourable“Nothing in this Lease relieves Landlord of the duty to make reasonable efforts to re-let the premises, and no provision shall be read otherwise.”
What this lease said“relieve the Landlord of its obligation to”
Landlord-favourable“Landlord's failure to re-let, or to collect the full rent from anyone else, shall not discharge Tenant's liability for rent.”
4

“premises is re-rented to”

Whether the unit is re-rented, and how hard anyone tried, is the factual centre of a New Jersey dispute. Sommer names what a court looks at: whether the landlord “offered or showed the apartment to any prospective tenants, or advertised it in local newspapers”. A landlord with other empty units “must treat the apartment in question as if it was one of his vacant stock”, and the court added that “there is no standard formula” for measuring the effort.

See the example
You can answer from your side as well. Sommer lets a tenant meet the landlord's evidence “by showing that he proffered suitable tenants who were rejected”, so keep the name of anyone you put forward and the date they were turned down.
Tenant-favourable“Tenant may propose replacement tenants, and Landlord shall not reject a suitable applicant without giving a written reason.”
What this lease said“premises is re-rented to”
Landlord-favourable“Landlord may decline any replacement Tenant proposes, for any reason or none, without reducing Tenant's liability.”
What the court did with it

The Montana Supreme Court struck this paragraph down, and its conclusion is one sentence: “Thus, we conclude that the accelerated rent provision is unconscionable and therefore unenforceable.” The tenants had moved out of their apartment on October 13, 2006, and Crestview answered with a Statement of Deductions from the Security Deposit charging rent through the end of the lease in June - $6,505.75 billed against a $2,170 deposit. Two reasons carried the court. Acceleration undermines the landlord's duty to mitigate and reduces the incentive to re-rent promptly, because a landlord already holding a judgment for the whole term has little reason to fill the unit. And Crestview drafted the lease while these tenants had no meaningful choice and no opportunity to negotiate any of it. The case was reversed and remanded, and two justices wrote separately - their objection being that the majority had gone as far as treating acceleration clauses as unenforceable in themselves. So read the holding narrowly, as the majority wrote it: this provision, in this residential lease, unconscionable and unenforceable. It is a Montana decision and it binds no other state's courts. What travels is the reasoning, and the reasoning is about mitigation - which is exactly the question the statute in your own city's decode answers.

How this state's law treats this clause
Our New Jersey record does not reach acceleration clauses by name. What it carries is a duty set by the state's Supreme Court, and the New Jersey sections it read contain no statute stating that duty. A landlord whose residential tenant wrongfully leaves must make a reasonable effort to re-let, and the landlord carries the burden of proving reasonable diligence. Read the opinion's current text yourself before relying on it: Sommer v. Kridel, 74 N.J. 446 (1977)

One court, one lease, one state. That answer is not automatically yours, and your lease may be worded to land differently. Use this to know what to look for and what to ask - your state's tenant hotline or a local tenant attorney can answer it for your document.

New Jersey Law on Lease Acceleration Clause

The law in New Jersey
  • Landlords must try to re-let.
    Read the law's wordsThe court wrote: "We now reverse and hold that a landlord does have an obligation to make a reasonable effort to mitigate damages in such a situation". It overruled the older decision, Joyce v. Bauman, "to the extent that it is inconsistent with our decision today".
  • The landlord carries the proof.
    Read the law's wordsThe opinion says "the landlord shall be required to carry the burden of proving that he used reasonable diligence in attempting to re-let the premises". A landlord with other vacant apartments "must treat the apartment in question as if it was one of his vacant stock".
  • Reasonable diligence is judged case by case.
    Read the law's wordsThe court's factors include whether the landlord "offered or showed the apartment to any prospective tenants, or advertised it in local newspapers". It also said "there is no standard formula" for measuring the effort.
  • A lease clause saying otherwise did not avoid the duty.
    Read the law's wordsKridel's own lease "stipulated that failure to re-let or to recover the full rental would not discharge the tenant's liability for rent", and the opinion ends: "The judgment in Sommer v. Kridel is reversed". In the companion case, Riverview Realty Co. v. Perosio, the court remanded "for proceedings in accordance with this opinion". It saw "no distinction between the leases involved in the instant appeals and those which might arise in other types of residential housing".

Sources include Sommer v. Kridel, 74 N.J. 446 (1977) - statutes change; verify the current text for your situation.

Read the full state law section

A New Jersey Supreme Court decision answers this. No New Jersey statute section we read states a duty to re-let. Those sections were Title 46, chapter 8, and in Title 2A, chapter 18 from § 2A:18-51 on, with chapters 39 and 42.

  • Sommer v. Kridel, 74 N.J. 446 (1977). The court held "that a landlord does have an obligation to make a reasonable effort to mitigate damages" when a residential tenant wrongfully leaves.
  • Who proves it. The landlord "shall be required to carry the burden of proving that he used reasonable diligence in attempting to re-let the premises". A landlord with other vacant apartments "must treat the apartment in question as if it was one of his vacant stock".
  • How effort is judged. Case by case, with "no standard formula". One factor is whether the landlord "offered or showed the apartment to any prospective tenants, or advertised it in local newspapers". A tenant may answer "by showing that he proffered suitable tenants who were rejected".
  • Who it covers. The court saw "no distinction" between the leases before it and those in other types of residential housing.

Our record of New Jersey law has no sentence on lease waivers and does not reach acceleration clauses by name. Read the current text of Sommer before relying on it.

What's Specific to Newark

No Newark Housing Code or Rent Control chapter we read sets a rule on re-renting or on acceleration clauses. That leaves your lease and Sommer v. Kridel as the documents to read side by side.

Sommer is a decision of New Jersey's Supreme Court, which is why it reaches a Newark tenancy; it was not decided about a Newark apartment. Ordinances change, so check the Newark code as it reads on the day you need it.

A Newark tenant lawyer or legal services office can weigh your lease wording against the opinion.

Does the lease say the landlord will try to re-rent if you leave?

That matches Sommer v. Kridel: a landlord must make a reasonable effort to re-let after a residential tenant wrongfully leaves.

Does it let you put forward a replacement tenant?

Useful in New Jersey. Under Sommer you can point to suitable tenants you put forward who were turned down.

Does it say failure to re-let will not reduce what you owe?

Kridel's own lease had wording like that, and the landlord's judgment was still reversed. Show such a line to a lawyer before you pay.

Does it make the whole remaining term payable at once?

Our record of New Jersey law does not reach acceleration clauses by name. Ask what was done to re-let before you pay any total.

Sources

The law this guide relies on, and where to read it. Statutes change, so confirm the current text before you act on it.

Red Flags to Watch Out For

  • A total with nothing about the unit

    The landlord must prove reasonable diligence in trying to re-let. Ask in writing what was done with the apartment, and when.

  • A set formula offered as the measure of effort

    The court said there is "no standard formula" for measuring the effort. Reasonable diligence is judged on the facts of each case.

  • Your unit held back while others were shown

    A landlord with other vacant apartments must treat yours as one of its vacant stock. Note which units were listed, and when.

  • Suitable applicants you found, turned away

    You can answer the landlord's case by showing suitable tenants you put forward who were rejected. Keep the names, dates and replies.

  • A letter citing a statute as the rule

    No New Jersey statute section we read states the duty to re-let; it comes from Sommer. Ask which section is meant and read it yourself.

Your Rights as a Newark Tenant

  • A reasonable effort to re-let

    A landlord must make a reasonable effort to mitigate damages when a residential tenant wrongfully leaves (Sommer v. Kridel).

  • The landlord proves its diligence

    The landlord, not you, carries the burden of proving it used reasonable diligence in attempting to re-let the premises.

  • Your replacement tenants count

    You may answer the landlord's evidence by showing suitable tenants you put forward who were rejected.

  • Not limited to one kind of housing

    The court saw no distinction between the leases before it and those in other types of residential housing.

What To Do - Step by Step

1

Write down every date

The day you told the landlord you were leaving, the day you returned the keys, and the last day of the term.

2

Offer replacement tenants in writing

Name anyone suitable who would take the unit, by email or letter. Keep any reply turning them down.

3

Save what you see of the re-letting

Screenshot listings and note signs or showings, with dates. The court asks whether the landlord showed or advertised the apartment.

4

Ask which other units stood empty

Ask in writing which units were vacant and which were shown. A landlord with other vacant apartments must treat yours as one of its vacant stock.

5

Check the Newark code as it reads today

Ordinances change. Confirm the current Housing Code and Rent Control chapters before relying on this page.

6

Read Sommer and get local advice

Read the current text of Sommer v. Kridel, 74 N.J. 446 (1977), then take the lease, dates and evidence to a Newark tenant lawyer or legal services office.

Why renters trust LeaseDecoded

Read at the sourceEvery statute is read in its published text, on the state's own site where that site can be reached.
Real court rulingsLease wording on our pages is quoted from published court opinions, with what the judge decided.
Dated and re-checkedEach guide shows when it was last reviewed, and we correct it when the law changes.
Free, no sign-upEvery guide and calculator is free. It is not legal advice; each guide says where to get that.

Frequently Asked Questions

does my landlord have to re-rent my apartment if i break my lease in newark
Yes, under a court decision. Sommer v. Kridel holds that a landlord must make a reasonable effort to re-let when a residential tenant wrongfully leaves, and must prove it used reasonable diligence.
can my landlord charge me all the remaining rent at once in newark nj
Our record of New Jersey law does not reach acceleration clauses, the lease lines that make all remaining rent due at once, by name. Under Sommer v. Kridel, a landlord claiming rent after you leave must prove reasonable diligence in trying to re-let.
who has to prove the landlord tried to re-rent in newark
The landlord. Under Sommer v. Kridel the landlord must prove it used reasonable diligence in attempting to re-let. You may answer by showing suitable tenants you put forward who were rejected.
does newark have its own rule on breaking a lease early
Not in the chapters we read. No Newark Housing Code or Rent Control chapter we read sets a rule on re-renting or acceleration clauses. The rule comes from New Jersey's Supreme Court in Sommer v. Kridel.
Legal Disclaimer: This guide is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Information reflects general New Jersey and Newark law as of October 2026 but may not reflect recent changes. Consult a licensed attorney in New Jersey for advice about your specific situation.